The lady with the dog, By Anton Chekhov (1899)

 The lady with the dog, By Anton Chekhov (1899)

8.5/10

For the first two parts of the story, I supposed this story was either an immoral, outrageous propaganda written to beautify cheating on partners, or a sort of cliché tragedy in which impossible love leads to emotional suicides and murders and such. Therefore, I was surprised when the author ended the story with the two lovers agonizing about their future.

However. once I read the story again and thought about it a few days after my first run, I felt that the behaviors of Gurov and Anna is something that should not be judged by our modern mindset. Instead, I began to understand the reason of their actions. A man internally disgusted by his monotonous life who never thought he would find real love met a woman he could finally love. What they thought to be a short immoral entertainment became the most important thing of their life, saving them from the distress of life.

Although I won’t change my thoughts that what Gurov and Anna are doing is wrong, I think Chekhov did an amazing job in showing the strange avidities and restrictions of life.

Thus, I rate this story eight point five out of ten. (197 words)

댓글

  1. Mr. Garrioch2022년 2월 27일 오후 6:23

    Good. I'm glad you noted the "ending" or lack of ending as important to the story. Chekhov isn't interested in drama. He is interested in the questions as he always is: what will humans accept as right or wrong, or bad or good? It is a messy question to answer.

    답글삭제

댓글 쓰기

이 블로그의 인기 게시물

"Araby" and stage 4 of the hero's journey

  In the stage four of the hero's journey, the hero of the story meets a mentor who provides the hero with wise advises and various forms of guidance. In this particular story of Araby, it is hard to specify a certain character as a mentor. The lesson is learned at the end of the story, and the hero stumbles into it without any guidance or help from other characters.   Still, the absence of a mentor is not a negative element. Instead, it maximizes the whole point of the story. The lamentable parts of life can be learnt only by experience. No mentor could teach it to us before we face it ourselves.
자세한 내용 보기

The Second Bakery Attack, By Haruki Murakami (1981)

 The Second Bakery Attack, By Haruki Murakami (1981) 9/10 Only after re-reading the story one more time to check whether there are any parts I might have missed, I realized that everything that happened in this story is unbelievably illogical. Waking up in the middle of the night in severe hunger is surely possible, but how in the world did that conclude into robbing a McDonalds and taking thirty bigmacs? It’s amazing how the author was able to make the situation seam logical and smooth. It was quite strange how what the couple did was a crime, but is still so humorous. Something about Haruki’s ways of explaining details such as the sleeping customers and paying for the drink makes even the most intense situations feel comical than serious. It gives the whole story a magical atmosphere. My favorite part of the story was how the narrator explains his feelings like floating on the ocean right above a volcano. It was very wholesome when the narrator decides to let the waves take h...
자세한 내용 보기

A Mother, By James Joyce (1914)

 A Mother, By James Joyce (1914) 7/10 It was interesting to see how Joyce tweaked what might have been a very cliché situation. In most situations where a mother protests about her daughter’s rightful. payment, she would seem brave and righteous. However, Mrs. Kearney seemed like the opposite of righteous. This may be because instead of protesting for her daughter, Mrs. Kearney is fighting for her pride. Unlike most good parents, Mrs. Kearney sees her children only as a tool to improve her social value and keep her pride. It was sad to see Kathleen not standing up to her mother, who might have just ruined her one chance of becoming a professional singer. Four guineas are not worth a lifelong job, let alone a dream coming true. This also reminded me about how big are the influence parents have on their children’s life. My favorite part of the story was how Mrs. Kearny blames Mr. Holohan and others. But the real reason she faced such humiliation was her own stubbornness. I rate...
자세한 내용 보기